By Terrence McCoy
By Scott Fishman
By Deirdra Funcheon
By Allie Conti
By New Times Staff
By Ryan Pfeffer
By Deirdra Funcheon
By Kyle Swenson
After an hour of casting various ballots and failing to figure out a foolproof formula to fill the most powerful nonelected position in the city of Fort Lauderdale, the commission decided to give up on math and hash it out with words.
They would go around the table, and each of the four commissioners and the mayor would say out loud who they wanted for the job of city manager. Commissioner Tim Smith was first. He chose Pete Witschen, the current assistant city manager with 12 years' experience in the job.
Next, Commissioner John Aurelius also chose Witschen, who showed no emotion as he sat watching the proceedings, his tall and and thin frame motionless.
So it came down to Mayor Jim Naugle, who would have the final say and break the two-two tie. Anticlimactically, Naugle declared that Michael White, the city administrator for West Palm Beach, was his first choice. Everyone in the cramped room on city hall's eighth floor knew White had no chance by that time.
Naugle then almost offhandedly remarked that in a race between Witschen and Johnson, he'd have to go with Johnson. That was all it took. The talking was finished and Johnson was quickly penciled in as the appointed city manager. All that's left is a routine background check and contract negotiations.
An hour after he made his decision, Naugle said he was glad he didn't have to disclose the reason he didn't choose Witschen. The mayor wasn't speaking of the obvious one -- that Witschen has long been allied with outgoing City Manager George Hanbury. Naugle and Hanbury openly despise one another, and the mayor had said that, if Witschen got the job, "it would just continue the dynasty, and more wrong decisions would be made."
But more important, Naugle says Witschen is unfit for the job. The reason: The mayor claims it's "common knowledge" among city officials that the 48-year-old Witschen has had romantic relationships with two city employees working in departments he was supervising.
"If the person at the top doesn't have strong character and set a good example, I think you have that reflected through the whole organization," Naugle said the day before the meeting. "I think it shows he shouldn't be the city manager."
While there is no written city policy against supervisors having such relationships with subordinates, Witschen's long-time boss, Hanbury, says he has his own rules prohibiting it, whether it's consensual or not. Liaisons between employer and employee are inappropriate, Hanbury says, and he won't allow them.
Employment lawyers say boss/subordinate romances are fraught with danger and could lead to dire complications in the modern workplace, not the least of which is a sexual harassment lawsuit, the experts say. In short, it's simply asking for trouble.
And that goes double in a political setting.
Witschen -- who's been a finalist for city manager positions in Boynton Beach, Miramar, Sunrise, and Tallahassee, but has never been chosen -- calls the allegations "vicious rumors." He also says he's "concerned" about them and acknowledges that they've been harmful to him.
But he doesn't deny them. He won't say he didn't have sexual relationships with a Fort Lauderdale police officer and a city planner while overseeing their respective departments.
Witschen, in fact, admits he had a romantic relationship with the planner, Clare Vickery, but says she was a "friend before she left [city employment], and after she left, we moved in together."
If by "friend," Witschen means it was platonic (he refused to clarify the matter), then their romantic courtship appeared to be extremely fast. Vickery, who is 32 years old, left her city job on January 9, 1997. She and Witschen bought property on which to build a house together on Valentine's Day, little more than a month later, according to land records. They've since broken up, and he's deeded his interest in the house back to Vickery. (Witschen recently married someone else.)
Vickery's departure from the city is clouded. She left the planning department, Naugle says, after Hanbury got wind of the affair and confronted Witschen about it.
Naugle says he was told by Hanbury himself that the city manager gave Witschen an ultimatum: Either the relationship ends, or one of the two would have to leave the city's employ.
While Hanbury, a strong supporter of his assistant Witschen, wouldn't deny that he confronted Witschen about it, he also wouldn't discuss it, calling it a "personnel matter." He did say he never delivered any ultimatum to Witschen.
"Whether I did or didn't get involved in this, I'm not going to respond to," Hanbury said. "I will say he's now a happily married man, a newlywed. There are people out there trying to smear his name, and I don't want to be a party to that."
When asked whether Hanbury addressed him about his relationship with Vickery, a defensive Witschen asked, "Who were you told that by? Do you have proof? Because before I say anything, I'd like to deal with some facts here."