Sports economist Andrew Zimbalist likens it to Major League Baseball allowing the Yankees, Red Sox, and Phillies to decide who makes the playoffs — and guarantee themselves the biggest paydays. So he and 21 other economists filed a complaint last spring that urged the Justice Department to investigate the BCS for antitrust violations.

Despite having access to the country's best mathematicians, many argue, the BCS still can't get its computer rankings right. Famed sports statistician Bill James has said they're based on "nonsense math." Hal Stern, a professor at the University of California-Irvine, has even called for a BCS boycott.

Then there are the university presidents. Faced with continuous funding cuts, at some point, they're bound to go looking for new revenue. Since March Madness generates more than $600 million a year, schools might belatedly realize that a playoff for football, the more popular sport, is sure to bring a torrent of cash. Fortunately, even those short on courage tend to find it when free money's in sight.

Bill Hancock, BCS executive director, says the bowl system rewards the athletes, but it's the bowl organizers who are getting rich.
Bill Hancock, BCS executive director, says the bowl system rewards the athletes, but it's the bowl organizers who are getting rich.

Hancock seems to know the end is near, though he won't say it outright. The BCS contract expires in 2014, and Hancock acknowledges that dozens of new proposals are floating around college football.

History says the insiders will try to change as little as possible. They've offered minor concessions every few years since the dawning of the BCS, just enough to keep attorneys general and nosy congressmen at bay. But the bowls' duplicity is so obvious, they can't hold on much longer.

"I want what's best for the students," Hancock says.

If he's being honest with himself, he can't help but push for reform. After all, he has to know that at the bottom of this insiders' pyramid are those who can afford it least — the kids paying tuition.

"What's really egregious is they shift that burden to their students," says Morgan.

That's the unholiest part of it all.

With reporting from Miami New Times Managing Editor Tim Elfrink.

« Previous Page
My Voice Nation Help

Who's going to break this mafia ring now that this mismagement of funds is brought to the forefront? There must be some organization that has the power to cease this kind of behavior.


Great article! 

This is exactly why I pay no attention to college football anymore. It's become even less of a sport than figure skating in the Olympics. 


The Orange Bowl Committee does wonderful things for the South Florida community.

All too typical
All too typical

Fort Lauderdale, Mayor Jack Seiler (D) is an Orange Bowl Committee Member.