It was a triumphant moment for music when Searching for Sugar Man won the Academy Award for best documentary last month. Yes, it was nice that after decades of anonymity, the subject of the movie, singer/songwriter Rodriguez got his day in the sun. But the award also validated what has, over the last decade, become the most consistently great genre in the world of film, the documentary about obscure musicians.
The story of the Beatles as told in The Beatles Anthology is crafted so well that you realize if the Beatles didn't exist, someone would have had to make them up. But everyone knows the Beatles did in fact exist. The genius of the documentary about the obscure musician is we are not entirely sure if it's made up or not.
If the goal of every movie is to give audiences a suspension of disbelief, the following five (supposedly true) movies are smash successes.
Spinal Tap. Anvil is a heavy metal band that trogged through hardship
for three decades. In spite of their awful music you can't help but root
for these underdogs to find success.
4. Searching For Sugar Man
Man, it seems impossible that a psychedelic troubadour who could give
Donovan and T Rex a run for their money would go unknown outside South
Africa for forty years.
Hollywood big budget movies never quite get right. Just delete from
your memory how Rodriguez's sound morphed into the realm of Jimmy
tried to ride the wave of alternative music toward mainstream success
should count, since one of the bands (the Dandy Warhols) was well-known
and the other found success after the release of the movie (the Brian
Jonestown Massacare perform the theme music for Boadwalk Empire). But
when Dig! was released, the out of control ego of Brian Jonestown Massacre
singer Anton Newcombe seemed like an attempt at a Saturday Night Live
parody. The scary part is, Newcombe's talent almost legitimizes the
2. Air Guitar Nation (2006)
are interesting stories. Even at the US Air Guitar Championships, where
you learn playing the air guitar can be as entertaining and inspiring as
any other instrument. You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll raise your hand, devil horns held high.
1. The Devil and Daniel Johnston (2005)
of Daniel Johnston who could have been a musical legend if he wasn't
afflicted by mental illness. As you hear the soundtrack, you see why Kurt
Cobain and Sonic Youth were devoted fans of Johnston. As the years go
by, the promising young man ages, your heart breaks. This
documentary brings up the great question of whether art causes men to
become mad or whether madness causes men to create art.
If you like this story, consider signing up for our email newsletters.
SHOW ME HOW
You have successfully signed up for your selected newsletter(s) - please keep an eye on your mailbox, we're movin' in!