What Happens When the Big Tent Folds?
Chris seems like the guy next door. Thirtysomething, well-built, clean-shaven, quick with conversation. He's spent most of his life in South Florida, making a living working in restaurants near the beach.
But Chris doesn't live next door to anyone. He's been out of housing and on the streets for three years. It's his choice, he says, because rents are too high. And he's tired of buying things only to have them stolen or repossessed. He has a regular place to sleep in a nook off Oakland Park Boulevard and carries his meager belongings with him in a tan bag.
Chris isn't his real name. He wouldn't give it. But his story is real and typical of hundreds of Broward County's homeless. In the county's current multimillion-dollar plan to solve its homeless problem, people like Chris will likely be ignored.
Chris steers clear of Fort Lauderdale's homeless encampment in a downtown parking lot, known as Tent City. A group of middle-aged men having a meal at the beach on Thanksgiving eve said they consider Tent City "legal anarchy" where the homeless go to buy and use drugs, where fights are picked for no reason, where personal belongings get stolen during the course of a shower.
And the men, like Chris, likely won't use the $7.7 million Homeless Assistance Center (HAC) set to begin construction after the holidays. They have jobs and don't have addictions, they claim. They don't want rules and expectations guiding their lives. They just want to live on the street.
But many Fort Lauderdale politicians would prefer not to see any homeless on the street, especially grown men walking through downtown carrying their belongings. Instead city officials want the homeless to find direction inside the HAC -- a 200-bed emergency shelter that will offer counseling and referrals to alcohol- and drug-abuse facilities, help with job training and placement, and aid in securing housing. When the HAC opens in January 1999, Tent City will come down, and any homeless person who isn't in some kind of treatment program someplace will be expected to leave town or could face arrest.
"It couldn't open soon enough for me," Fort Lauderdale Vice Mayor Tim Smith says of the HAC, implying as well that Tent City can't close soon enough. "Every human being has a responsibility to help themselves. If help is offered, you gotta take it, or you gotta go away."
"Our plan is that when the HAC is operative, Tent City will close," Fort Lauderdale Mayor Jim Naugle says. "We feel under the law that having that facility open, we can enforce our no-trespass laws. It's our intent to close Tent City and enforce our laws."
Homeless advocates, while opposing Tent City almost as vehemently as politicians because of its cramped and depressing conditions, say this plan to keep the homeless out of sight could put the city in court.
"I'm sure they [Fort Lauderdale officials] intend to arrest people for being on the street, but they'll face some trouble for that," says Janet Riley, a lawyer with Florida Legal Services, an agency that offers legal help to the poor. Riley sued the city in 1994 on behalf of its homeless residents because of the unhealthy and crowded conditions in Tent City.
"You don't have to be a brain surgeon to figure out that Fort Lauderdale is going to open up that HAC and think that's the end of the homeless problem," Riley says. "I think the HAC is a great thing, a vital thing, but we cannot think it'll be the end-all and be-all of this problem."
To city officials the homeless "problem" is that which they see, the soiled and lost souls panhandling money on highway exit ramps, the drunken ones sleeping in downtown doorways. The HAC will give officials the authority, as Naugle says, to take someone to treatment or to enforce laws to keep those folks off the street.
The reason police aren't doing that now is because of a lawsuit known as the Pottinger case. Michael Pottinger is the lead plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit against the city of Miami over its handling of the homeless. Federal Judge C. Clyde Atkins ruled in 1992 that the city had to provide safe zones where the homeless could bathe and sleep without fear of arrest.
Fort Lauderdale officials interpreted Pottinger to mean they could not arrest park vagrants without a "safe zone" and so erected Tent City in late 1993.
Since the lawsuit was filed in 1988, Miami has designed a plan to help the homeless that includes job training and placement, mental-health counseling, and addiction treatment. The city has promised to open three assistance centers, one of which is already open in Overtown, and has implemented a countywide food-and-beverage tax that brings in $6 million a year to pay for it all. Miami's strategy has won accolades from the Clinton administration and from city administrators across the nation.
In light of that progress, Miami officials have asked Atkins to eliminate the safe zones and free police to make arrests when appropriate. The nearly ten-year-old Pottinger case is in settlement negotiations and a resolution is expected perhaps by the end of the year. Once a decision is reached, Fort Lauderdale officials will know better if the HAC will enable them to clear their downtown streets of homeless people.
But homeless people like Chris, who neither look homeless nor seek to change their lifestyles, likely will avoid either arrest or treatment and continue living on the street.
Neither an addict nor lacking job skills, Chris has no use for the HAC. Neither disheveled nor lacking goals, he won't be targeted as an undesirable and forced to leave town.
For him the solution can be as simple as finding affordable housing that isn't surrounded by drug dealers, having more access to transportation to get to work, and finding a regular shower.
Steve Werthman, the contract administrator between Broward County and HAC, says the county is applying for $29 million in federal grants to help expand programs for the homeless, as well as to create new ones. That money hasn't been available to Broward County before because it didn't have a working plan to help the homeless.
Until some of that money comes through, however, the only new services will be in the HAC, the first stop along a "continuum of care." Designs for the HAC would include emergency shelter for as many as 200 homeless, counseling services for clients who can stay between seven and sixty days, placement in transitional housing, and help finding permanent affordable housing.
But there is insufficient transitional and affordable housing available in Broward County, and county officials have been unable in past years to get federal funding for more because it had no plan to combat homelessness. So the HAC has been touted as a way to open funding doors and to let Broward County get a handle on its 6000 homeless, about 1000 of whom are children.
For details of the HAC's social programs, Werthman referred questions to William Keith, president of the HAC's board and a principal at the influential engineering firm of Keith and Schnars.
Keith says it's too early to talk about what kind of programs the HAC will provide. The board, created four months ago, has concentrated on raising $3 million and negotiating the finer points of landscaping at the three-acre site at Sunrise Boulevard and Northwest Seventh Avenue to appease neighborhood residents and business owners.
"Our initial thrust was to get our site, get the permits and start construction," Keith says. "Things just take time."
When asked about the HAC's social programs, Keith indicated that other facilities in town would provide that kind of help and referred questions to Werthman.
Several homeless advocates questioned whether Keith's board could properly handle the task of designing programs to help the homeless. The board is composed of 26 volunteers from around the county, mostly lawyers, business executives, engineers, and contractors.
"It's the power brokers," says Arnold Abbott, founder of Love Thy Neighbor, who coordinates meals at Tent City. "It's appalling to me that not one of them has any experience with the homeless, except not wanting them around."
Only one board member holds a position with a social service that helps the poor and homeless -- Kevin Leonard, president of the board of directors for Henderson Mental Health Center. The executive director of the Broward Coalition for the Homeless, Laura Carey, has been appointed as an ex officio member.
"Yes, we felt as though someone from the Coalition should have been on the board," says Dianne Sepielli, former president of the Coalition. "When we first saw it, we said, 'oh my goodness. You see a lot of power, but where's the heart?'"
Allen Reesor, current president of the coalition and director of the Broward Outreach Center, the county's first homeless shelter, in Hollywood, says he thinks the HAC board should be restructured to accommodate more homeless advocates and social service agencies once the construction phases are completed.
At a recent workshop sponsored by the HAC board, Vice Chairman Elliot Borkson, a lawyer with Atlas Pearlman Trop & Borkson, could not answer audience questions about tuberculosis contamination among clients, how the HAC's programs would differ from what the Salvation Army provides, or what educational opportunities would be available.
"A lot of us don't even understand what homelessness is about," Borkson admitted. "I don't understand it when I see people on the street. But it happens, and I know some of these people just need a little help."
But there are hundreds of people who need a lot of help and hundreds more, like Chris, who want no help at all in getting off the streets. The Coalition has begun working on how to reach those two groups and avert the inevitable conflict that will arise when the HAC opens and Tent City closes.
"There needs to be some sort of safe zone, perhaps something similar to St. Laurence Chapel," Reesor says, referring to a day center for homeless people in Pompano Beach where people can get a shower and a hot meal. "We've got to come up with something.
Get the Weekly Newsletter
Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.
- Patricia Montes Sentenced for Participation in Rape and Beating of Friend After...
- Pat Riley on Offseason Without LeBron: "No More Smiling Faces With Hidden Agendas"
- Florida's Largest Solar Project Is a Win for Utilities, Loss for Private Industry and...
- New Report Criticizes GEO Group for Making Big Bucks Off Immigrant Backs