The First Thanksgiving Was in Florida, Not Plymouth Rock
Stop stuffing the turkey! Stop mashing the potatoes! We've had it wrong all along, the first real Thanksgiving was not at Plymouth Rock in 1621. It was 50 years earlier in Florida.
The strife of our country's first colonists as they sailed on the Mayflower seeking religious freedom is a crucial part of our nation's history. And in 1621 when they feasted with the Wampanoag Indians over poultry and maize, it was a sign that the worst was over. Every fourth Thursday of November we re-create that initial Thanksgiving.
But, according to one author, it was on September 8, 1565 that the first Thanksgiving actually occurred in Florida.
In 1513 Juan Ponce de Leon discovered Florida and declared the peninsula Spain's. The Spanish king then sent Pedro Menendez de Aviles to Florida to start a permanent territory. His fleet landed in modern-day St. Augustine and encountered the Timcuan Indians.
The Timcuan brought oysters and clams. The Spanish brought a dish of garbanzo beans and salted pork called cocido.
"[St. Augustine] is the oldest city in the nation," Robyn Giola, author of "America's REAL First Thanksgiving" says. "It doesn't matter what group is there. A lot of people think that only English history is valid."
Giola teaches at a school in Jacksonville. She was at a week-long teacher's workshop in St. Augustine and heard Dr. Michael Gannon, a researcher at the University of Florida, speak.
"[Dr. Gannon] proved that St. Augustine was the oldest city in the nation, it also made the Thanksgiving that took place then the first Thanksgiving," Giola explains in an email (she's currently teaching in Japan).
According to Giola, Dr. Gannon's findings was challenged by traditionalists and academics. He was even nicknamed the Grinch Who Stole Thanksgiving. But Giola understands that this is an integral part of not just our state's history, but our nation's history. She wrote her children's book in 2007 to help spread the word. It's currently available online, in most public librarys, and the governor's library.
"I love our traditional Thanksgiving and how it has grown to be a wonderful family day," Giola says. "But I also think there is room for recognizing the first Thanksgiving on September 8 with a bowl of cocido."
Get the Food & Drink Newsletter
Our weekly guide to South Florida dining includes food news and reviews, as well as dining events and interviews with chefs and restaurant owners.