Navigation

Nancy Grace Show to Feature Juliana Mensch Murder Tonight

(Running updates whenever we add another article about the case)Tonight at 8, the Nancy Grace Show on HLN will feature the murder of Juliana Mench, the 19-year-old found strangled in a room in Fort Lauderdale in March. Barring some kind of creative editing, a certain Pulp blogger wearing a charming...
Share this:

(Running updates whenever we add another article about the case)


Tonight at 8, the Nancy Grace Show on HLN will feature the murder of Juliana Mench, the 19-year-old found strangled in a room in Fort Lauderdale in March. Barring some kind of creative editing, a certain Pulp blogger wearing a charming red and black tie will be featured, in between a bunch of lawyers and commentators of every stripe.

They will also dedicate a considerable amount of time to reenacting the text messages between James Ayers and Nicole Okrzesik, the accused killers. And yes, Casey Anthony was mentioned.

We've been covering the story since Ayers was arrested at the end of March; here's a quick rundown of the stories we've put together for anyone not familiar with the case.


March 30: Our first story about the crime; not a lot was available at the time, but it was the first we heard about Ayers, a woman named Julie, and a dead body.

April 2: The details start coming out -- police said Ayers was arrested after driving around in Mensch's car and telling his friend he strangled her.

April 3: There was a hint of a chest tattoo in Ayers' mug shot -- turns out it says "Sicker Than Most," and he claimed on Facebook to have done it himself.

April 25: Just some quick info about Ayers' first court date.

May 2: The court date was set, but his lawyer said there were still mental health questions about Ayers' competency.

May 11: More than a month after the crime, Okrzesik was arrested at the drug-treatment facility she checked into in the days following the murder.

May 14: Text messages between Ayers and Okrzesik show the two allegedly arguing over what to do with Mensch's body and whether to turn themselves in.

May 21: Internet records from Okrzesik's phone show searches for some creepy things while Mench reportedly slept on the floor next to her.

May 29: The long electronic trail Ayers and Okrzesik left gets creepier -- they checked in on Facebook at Wet Willie's the same day Mensch died, and continued their text argument about the body via Facebook chat in the days after that.

June 7: A grand jury ruled Okrzesik should stand trial with Ayers June 25.

KEEP NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of South Florida, and we'd like to keep it that way. Your membership allows us to continue offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food, and culture with no paywalls. You can support us by joining as a member for as little as $1.