So if jokes about farting in peoples' faces, graphic scenes of vomiting, gratuitous references to urination and spitting, and Heder picking his nose the whole movie sound amusing to you, this might be your idea of fun. On the other hand, you could just try babysitting a toddler or two instead. You'd get all the bodily functions, plus a sense of humor that's better-developed than Dugan's.
Heder and Spade play Clark and Richie, hopeless nerds who aren't even good at their relatively unchallenging jobs. Clark's a paperboy, never seen without his bike helmet, who still lives with his mother and gets excited about macaroni for dinner. Richie, whose hideous bowl haircut vaguely resembles a bike helmet, is a video store clerk who recommends lesbian porn to female customers. Their friend Gus (Schneider) is a landscaper who appears to be a nerd but, when challenged to a baseball game by some obnoxious kids, proves to be really good at it. Indeed, he's not in the same league as his friends he has a beautiful wife and a past he's ashamed of for different reasons. This isn't that different from, say, David Spade in real life; Richie may be a 30-something virgin, but Spade has dated the likes of Kristy Swanson. In other words, kids, he ain't one of you, but he gets his fame pretending to be, which turns out to be Gus' major dilemma in the movie.
After beating the obnoxious kids, Gus, Clark, and Richie are challenged by the boys' obnoxious parents, fronted by the smarmy Jerry (Craig Kilborn). When Gus stands up for his buddies, it catches the eye of local bazillionaire Mel (Jon Lovitz), a guy so geeky he collects life-sized Star Wars figures and owns the original Adam West Batmobile. It's his idea to form a team of apparent losers called The Benchwarmers, to give the kids who never get to play ball a chance to be in the game. With a brand-new stadium at stake, he sets up a tournament pitting the three adults against full teams of obnoxious kids with even more obnoxious parents.
If the idea of a team of misfit nerds coming together to play baseball seems familiar, it might just be because there was already one remake of The Bad News Bears, which was a whole lot funnier than this inept, inbred knockoff. A couple of Sandler-movie trademarks are recognizable there's a foul-mouthed, crazy senior citizen and a gratuitous David Hasselhoff reference. It's symptomatic of how lazy the movie is that we never even learn how Mel went from being a school loser to the richest guy in town. What, they couldn't think of some funny way to make money? No, the "best" joke they can come up with for Mel is that he lives on Shmegmer Street.
Look, it's not like Happy Madison Productions has ever set the bar all that high, but even based on the low expectations a viewer might have based on The Waterboy, The Animal, or Dickie Roberts: Former Child Star, this film disappoints. Heder in particular is someone you might expect better from, though based on this and Just Like Heaven, he might want to place his SAG card under glass until the next Napoleon Dynamite sequel.