Film Reviews

Stoner Eisenberg Discovers Spy Powers in the Ace American Ultra

Nima Nourizadeh's American Ultra is a bloody valentine attached to a bomb. It's violent, brash, inventive, and horrific and perhaps the most romantic film of the year. Jesse Eisenberg and Kristen Stewart star as Mike and Phoebe, two West Virginia stoners blissed out on weed and each other. "We're the perfect fucked-up couple," Mike beams before admitting she's perfect and he's the fuck-up. And as the movie begins, Mike has scraped up the cash for a chintzy engagement ring so he can spend the rest of his life kinda ruining hers: having panic attacks that prevent them from traveling, forcing her to cook lest he burn down the house, and supporting them on his meager paycheck from the minimart. (Phoebe mans the phones for a bail bondsman — convenient because Mike is continually arrested for possession.)

With other actors, this could play like slapstick. Swap out Eisenberg for Ashton Kutcher, and American Ultra would become a flat comedy. But Eisenberg mines Mike for pathos — he's not a punch line; he's a flake who knows he's his own worst enemy. There's a Mike in every town, a smart guy who can't stop screwing up. Early on, Mike tokes while gazing at an automobile wreck. It hits him: Lively, pink-haired Phoebe is the car, and he's the tree that's stopped her dead. You expect Eisenberg, the brittle brainiac, to deliver the line like an insecure quip. Instead, he begins to cry.

It's laced with jokes but aimed deeper into our guts.

tweet this

Yet it's Stewart who makes this loony love story work. She takes what could easily be a simple supportive-girlfriend role — a cheerleader enabler — and fills Phoebe with a rainbow of emotions. Stewart's Phoebe looks at Mike like she sees exactly who he is, and picks him anyway. She knows how much of their future is on her shoulders. As the hostile local sheriff chides, "You're his girlfriend, you're his mom, you're his maid, you're his landlady." True, but she's still no pushover. When she unpacks their suitcase from another failed vacation (Mike vomited at the airport), Stewart silently channels Phoebe's sadness, and then, with a small smile, shows her forgive.

The big twist is none of us know exactly who Mike is — not even Mike. One night outside the Cash & Carry, Mike looks up at the stars, and this disheveled domestic drama turns into a thriller. The camera zooms up to a satellite and then beams to CIA headquarters, where a garbled caller informs Agent Lasseter (Connie Britton) that Mike will be murdered within 24 hours. Agent Yates (Topher Grace), a vile twerp, commanded the execution and shipped 20 killers to West Virginia, including a repellent hick named Laugher (Walton Goggins) whose exhalations through his missing teeth sound like a ghost whistling across a grave.

It's no shock to moviegoers that Mike has been programmed with surprise skills, though it is to him. "I could list like 50 types of tanks right now," he exclaims after Lasseter activates him so he can try to stay alive. We've seen that plot point in a dozen dumb movies. What is shocking is how smart American Ultra is at being dumb — its emotional intelligence is off the charts. Max Landis' script isn't the usual whiz-bang wish fulfillment that assures us even losers can be special. It's a real romance about two people trying to survive, and Eisenberg captures the horror of suddenly realizing your life has been a lie. "What if I'm a robot?" he bleats. Once again, it's up to Phoebe to steady her fragile man — and the movie around him. "You're not a robot," she insists. Would a robot wail after stabbing a man with a spoon? Would it decide it would rather stop fighting, crawl into bed with a bong, and die smiling?

What happens to Mike and Phoebe is hard to watch. Nourizadeh keeps the effects of violence painfully real: As the blood, bruises, and busted lips rack up, we look at the lovebirds and wince. But Nourizadeh is a sadist with a sense of humor. His fatal weapons include dustpans, skillets, frozen hamburgers, and cans of tomatoes. He's an ingenious director of action. No matter how crazy the brawl, we know the geometry of the scene, and we can follow Mike's intentions with an eye-flick.

Better still, Nourizadeh is ruthless with the audience's empathy. Villains have moments of heart; good people wind up on the wrong end of a gun. And he's got the control to both hold a camera still when fists are flying and whip us into frenzies with a wild montage, ripping through Mike and Phoebe's relationship at light-speed without skimming past its soul.

American Ultra is astonishingly alive. It feels at once young and angry, unhinged and sincere, like a teenager scribbling "Screw you" to everyone but his first crush. It's laced with jokes but aimed deeper into our guts. Any movie could shoot a scene of Jesse Eisenberg emerging from a cloud of smoke in a bloody Hawaiian shirt for laughs. Only this movie could do it to make you cry.

KEEP NEW TIMES BROWARD-PALM BEACH FREE... Since we started New Times Broward-Palm Beach, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of South Florida, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Amy Nicholson was chief film critic at LA Weekly from 2013 to 2016. Her work also appeared in the other Voice Media Group publications – DenverWestword, Phoenix New Times, Miami New Times, Broward-Palm Beach New Times, Houston Press, Dallas Observer and OC Weekly – and in VMG’s film partner, the Village Voice.

Nicholson’s criticism was recognized by the Los Angeles Press Club and the Association of Alternative Newsmedia. Her first book, Tom Cruise: Anatomy of an Actor, was published in 2014 by Cahiers du Cinema.