New Times: You put out a split 12-inch with Sleeping States in honor of LGBT pride this past June. Califone's Brian Deck remixed your album Academy Songs, Volume 1 into one song. Were you happy with the result? And why'd you guys chose to present it in this format?
John Orth: Brian and I have been friends for years. I worked with him recording the Ugly Casanova record and on Holopaw's first recording. I was visiting him awhile back in Chicago, and I casually mentioned that based on the Modest Mouse remixes I had heard that he should be remixing entire records (Jaime xx had just remixed Gil Scott-Heron).
Brian agreed, saying that, first and foremost, he should remix the songs that would become Academy Songs, Volume 1. I said that might be a good idea and grinned all the way home.
I couldn't be more pleased with the result. Personally, I was touched to be working with Brian again. Moreover, hearing the record filtered through Brian's imagination allowed me to hear those songs again. The recording and mixing process is tedious. I was weary of those songs. Brian brought them back to life for me.
The album was based on an all-boys prep school. Did you attend one, or is it all fantasy and metaphor?
Fantasy and metaphor, I suppose. When I was growing up my mom was a yearbook editor for my junior high. She had yearbooks from schools around the country that she used as examples. One of them was from an all-boys boarding school in upstate New York. As a boy very much aware of my sexual interest, the thought of living in close proximity to other boys was both thrilling and terrifying. I poured through the pages of the yearbook again and again. I studied their faces, parsed their senior quotes, imagined their secret societies and after "lights out" conversations. In setting Academy Songs in the all-boys prep school, I was trying to recapture the energy and anxiety illicited for me by those pages so many years ago.
Is there a Volume II on the way?
Yes. We are just starting the writing process towards Volume II. Saturday we will be performing two new songs, "Tiger. Tiger" and a brand new song, as of now untitled.
Some proceeds from sales went to the Point Foundation. Did you have any say in what org was sponsored? Can you tell us about this one?
The Point Foundation was actually brought to our attention by our, very enlightened label manager, Leo DeLuca. We are proud to be on a label that thought it important to mark LBGT pride month with a release and was willing to give part of the proceeds to a righteous organization. The Point Foundation gives scholarships to lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer students in need. Rad!
I just got back to London and my gay friends there were kind of talking about how the gay underground is sort of dead and being gay has mainstreamed. Gay marriage is legal there, so it's a different scene. This is sort of a reductive question, but do you think that "gay" can still be "edgy"?
My friend Adam (Baran) and I are working on a video in a couple weeks for the song "He Don't." It stars the internet phenom Bearded Boy who is famous for, among other things, posing with cum in his beard. Edgy? (laughs)
I will say, on a more serious note, that no matter how many sitcom stages we mince across, how many corporations decide we are a bankable demographic or how many well deserved civil rights we achieve, our numbers and our unique comings of age will always make us "others." We should embrace that otherness and not strive to become "Jeep fags," as my friend Steven calls those that long to "pass" in mainstream culture by blunting their sexuality and creative expression. No Jeep fags. (laughs)
That's why you were looking for "open-minded, queer male-identified actors and performers" to play "members of a raucous gay leather biker gang for a sexually charged music video" in New York. That sounds fun! What did (former BUTT Magazine editor) Adam Baran do with this gang?
Adam is a friend of mine I met through Butt Magazine a few years back. We played at the Knitting Factory this past February. He and a couple hundred other generous souls walked through a blizzard to see us. Afterwards, he said he would like to make a video for the new record. Adam is also an accomplished filmaker.
We decided to work with the song "He Don't" which is a queering of the Shangri-Las' song "Out in the Streets." The video in broad strokes: girl group melodrama, a queer biker gang headed by the aforementioned Bearded Boy, a "boys will be boys" night out, nods to filmmakers Kenneth Anger, James Bidgood, and various gay porn auteurs of the '70s, styling inspired by Swiss photographer Karlheinz Weinberg and featuring a voice over by porn legend, Peter Berlin. O.K., that was fairly specific.