Indeed, only a handful of his South Florida fans realize that Smith is considered one of the finest jazz organists in the world. During the '60s and '70s, the good doctor -- peer-appointed, naturally -- enthralled audiences with his funky, groove-driven tunes. Down Beat magazine declared him organist of the year in 1969. He played for years with guitarist George Benson, as well as saxophonist Lou Donaldson and other jazzgreats.
These days Smith plays a few nights a week, mostly at the O'Hara's in Fort Lauderdale but once a week, as well, at the club's Hollywood location. He favors a turban, flowing robes, bracelets, rings, a white beard, and a walking stick. In Hollywood he plays his beloved organ. In Lauderdale he performs atop a stack of three plastic chairs, a white-plastic tip jar sitting on his Yamaha keyboard.
But his storied musical career actually began in Buffalo, New York, where his musical talent first emerged. "I could always play," Smith says. "Ever since I sat me down at a piano, I always picked up songs easily." To prove the point, Smith shuffles over to the grand piano in the living room of his Fort Lauderdale home and begins playing a gospel song called "Crying in the Chapel," the first tune he everlearned.
Smith actually began his career as a doo-wop singer, recording with a band called the Supremes (not the Diana Ross version), and later with the Teen Kings, performing at sock hops and on local Buffalo television shows alongside Fabian and the Mills Brothers.
But he quickly found his passion playing piano and organ. The problem? He wasn't very good at first. He fondly remembers his first out-of-town gig, at the Hurricane Lounge in Pittsburgh. "The owner wanted me to go," he says, with a chuckle. "I couldn't play very well, so I'd practice in the off hours or on stage, and within a week I blew heraway."
Smith toured clubs throughout the Midwest and East Coast. But it was back in Buffalo that he first met rising guitarist George Benson. "When I thought about organ players, he came into my mind, because he can swing," Benson recalled in a 1967 interview with Down Beat. "When I called him, he was working with a rhythm-and-blues group, but he decided to take a chance with me, although I had nothing linedup."
Benson and Smith gigged regularly around New York City, and a number of record companies did come courting. But they waited for the right deal. "Then one day, sure enough, the biggie came in: John Hammond with Columbia records," Smith recalls. After seeing them once, Hammond signed Benson and Smith to separate deals. Soon after that, Smith recorded his first solo album, Finger Lickin' Good. A gig at Newport Jazz Festival followed.
In 1967 Smith joined Benson and saxophonist Lou Donaldson on Donaldson's composition "Alligator Boogaloo." The track was an instant smash, taking jukeboxes by storm and helping to popularize Smith's hip, soulful sound. "Everyone started to play that funk-groove jazz," recalls Donaldson, still a good friend and collaborator of Smith's. "Especially with the organs. When it was happening, we didn't think about it. Looking back, I can see exactly what was happening. But at the time we were on the road with a whole lot of stuff going on. We didn't even concentrate on it toomuch."
Smith continued to play with both Donaldson and Benson. Despite all the sudden activity, Smith remained focused on his own music. "I just wanted to play my instrument," he notes. "That's all I was thinking about. I just wanted to be good at what I did. I wasn't thinking about any big time." But Smith's soulful style helped set the standard for jazz organists, and he was soon being courted by Duke Pearson of Blue Note records.
"I will never forget that," Smith says fondly. "I used to get a lot of Blue Note records. All the people I loved were on that label. I tried to act like I wasn't excited, but I was. I had finally done it." From 1968 to 1970, Smith recorded five albums for Blue Note, Think, Turning Point, Move Your Hand, Drives, and Live at Club Mozambique. The title track on the LP Move Your Hand proved to be asmash.
But Smith was never too crazy about the commercial pressures of his stardom. Rather than regurgitating hits from his albums, Smith was more interested in playing his new material, which didn't go over too well with his audiences. "I didn't like the star system. I guess I was a rebel, though I didn't even know I was a rebel."