Critic's Notebook

will.i.am

Derivative, repetitive, insipid, insincere, and pandering, Songs About Girls also has the worst insert booklet in recent memory — seven pages of will.i.am mugging in a checkered suit. Get over yourself! To be fair, the first song, "Over," a lover's lament featuring a sample from Electric Light Orchestra (never a...
Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Derivative, repetitive, insipid, insincere, and pandering, Songs About Girls also has the worst insert booklet in recent memory — seven pages of will.i.am mugging in a checkered suit. Get over yourself! To be fair, the first song, “Over,” a lover’s lament featuring a sample from Electric Light Orchestra (never a bad thing) isn’t terrible. But with a first single like “I Got It From My Mama,” the ship crashes directly into the iceberg. It’s an almost note-for-note rip-off of “My Humps,” which means, we guess, that there’s a new worst single of the millennium. On “The Donque Song,” Snoop regurgitates some of his Doggystyle rhymes over a techno beat, and then, on “One More Chance,” will vomits up this gem: “I know you want more than a dick in ya/You want a good nigga to stick with ya.” “Fantastic” contains yet another sample of the Jackson 5’s “I Want You Back,” and “S.O.S.” (are we done yet?) is an anti-global-warming power ballad. It’s hard to get upset about it. Perhaps the culture that produced this album deserves our fate.

GET MORE COVERAGE LIKE THIS

Sign up for the Music newsletter to get the latest stories delivered to your inbox

Loading latest posts...