Letters for August 29, 2002 | Letters | South Florida | Broward Palm Beach New Times | The Leading Independent News Source in Broward-Palm Beach, Florida

Letters for August 29, 2002

Shine on: I love reading features in New Times and other alternative newspapers, and I found Eric Alan Barton's August 15 story, "So Long, Skid Row," particularly interesting.

I would like to know if y'all think that shining a light on social issues has helped alleviate the problems that you write about such as homelessness or prostitution, etc. Does public embarrassment or public awareness bring anything to fruition?

Deborah Rubinstein

San Antonio, TX

We got tune: I am a long-time reader of alternative news... coming from Dallas, I started off with the Observer and graduated to New Times when I moved to Miami. Recently relocated to Broward, I'm once again a keeper of New Times.

Is it that there truly is no music or no music following here, or do you need some help getting organized at NT? I have swallowed the hard fact that I no longer live a stone's throw from Greenville and all its guitar legacies, and Austin has gone from being a short road trip to a five-hour plane flight, but surely South Florida is not this musically deficient and/or unorganized?

I find it so frustrating that I can't grab a paper and easily find a listing of who is playing at what joint and when on a well-laid out, easy-to-read calendar.

But the Marlins schedules are easy to find, so who the hell knows, right?

Musically deprived in SoFla.

Marie Henley

via the Internet

Editor's note: Thanks for the chance to introduce our new club listings person, Marli Guzzetta. E-mail her at [email protected] newtimesbpb.com. Then complain, complain, complain.

Looking for answers: I read with great interest Bob Norman's August 1 article, "The War Within." Given the importance of this topic for Americans, you are to be congratulated for publishing this important article so that neighbors in Broward and Palm Beach counties can have a calm and dispassionate forum in which to raise questions. There are too many people worldwide who are ready and willing to shed more heat than light on the topic and to misrepresent one another.

I ask you to pose some questions to our Muslim neighbors. I would hope they would respond in the same spirit to your paper.

What's the definition of a true Muslim? It seems to me that, nowadays as in some times past, there is some controversy within the Muslim community.

What is militant Islam? One image, as portrayed by the so-called fundamentalist Muslims, is that of Muslims willing not only to defend their personal beliefs but also to expand Islam by force, if necessary. These would include Hezbollah, Hamas, the Muslim Brotherhood, and movements in the Philippines, Indonesia, Algeria, and the Sudan. How do our Muslim neighbors and friends here in Florida feel about this?

Though Islam is called "the religion of tolerance," there are many Muslims, the great majority, I believe, who would by no means agree with coercing nonbelievers to adhere to Islam by force, much less by the threat of death. I know them to be a loving, kind, and hospitable people. The Qur'an states, "Let there be no compulsion in religion" (Sura 2:256).

What is the final word in the Qur'an? Which image, or model, of a true Muslim adheres more closely and genuinely to the ideal image of a Muslim as described in the Holy Writ of Islam? The Qur'an evidently has two teachings on this matter. There are other verses that appear later in Qur'anic writings that state: "When the sacred months are past, kill those who join other gods wherever you find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them with every kind of ambush; but if they convert and observe prayer and pay the obligatory alms, let them go their way" (Sura 9:5); and "O Prophet, strive hard against the unbelievers and the hypocrites, and be firm against them. Their abode is Hell, an evil refuge, indeed" (Sura 9:73).

The latter writing supercedes the former. When there are apparent contradictions in the Qur'an, is it not true that there is an Islamic theological principle that states that the latter verse supercedes the former? Should we not assume that this line of reasoning would have been used last year by Osama bin Laden and other members of al Qaeda?

Sean M. Walsh


A Hollywood proto-sphinx: After reading "The War Within," I must conclude that Rafiq Mahdi is a hateful Muslim who speaks out of both sides of his mouth. For example, he says that suicide bombers are not "viable military operations," yet he finds it "difficult to blanketly condemn suicide bombings." I guess if they were viable, he'd openly approve them. What a pragmatist!

Although we've all heard and seen Osama bin Laden on tape rejoicing about the success of his terrorists' efforts to destroy the World Trade Center, Mahdi isn't convinced that bin Laden was behind the attacks. That's like saying Yasser Arafat isn't a terrorist!

Mahdi criticizes "the Jewish occupation of Palestine," but I must remind him that, first, there is no place called Palestine and, next, that Israel won the land in defensive wars fought against, among others, the Jordanian and Egyptian armies. No so-called-Palestinians ever controlled that land. Simply, what fundamentalist radicals like Mahdi can't stand is that Jews beat the butts of Arabs in five wars!

Harvey Slavin


Uptown tyranny: In regard to the July 11 letter by Eric Wagner. It's unfortunate that he and his fiancée had to deal with the "police state" instead of Florida State with regards to the DMV. Wagner is exactly correct stating that because the DMV employee is part of the police state apparatus, the innocent are now the guilty ones. I ask, "Is it time for the people of Florida to rise up and revolt with an armed revolution?"

Thomas Jefferson (one of our founding fathers) wrote, "We must keep a constant vigil against tyranny within our own government." Let's keep an eye on the proceedings of our own Broward Sheriff's Office! It's our duty as Americans and Floridians.

John Lazarra

via the Internet

Down-the-river tyranny: This letter is in regard to two letters I read in your publication. The first letter concerned Florida (the police state). The second concerned the ongoing church and state fiasco ("First Pledge," Bob Norman, July 11).

To begin with, let me say the following: God is not affected in any way, shape, or form by anyone's opinion of him! This country was established (duh!) specifically so that citizens could and would be allowed to freely pursue, observe, and maintain freedom of religion. No amount of semantics can change this reality. No amount of hyperbole can erase the fact that many people gave their lives to establish this country for future generations.

Anyone with an IQ that is considered average or above should readily be able to discern that our government is using 9/11 to successfully strip us of our constitutional rights. Florida's second-largest source of income is derived from prisons and industries associated with the Florida Department of Corrections. This can easily be verified. While I was incarcerated, I became aware of several uncommon laws and statutes that Florida maintains. There is no justifiable homicide, no self-defense.

We are supposed to be considered in-nocent until proven guilty. In reality, the opposite prevails. Not only is Florida a "prison state" but I've found nearly every facet of industry (public and private) to be inefficient and non-service-oriented. Either they don't know or they don't care.

Chuck Fornataro

West Palm Beach

Correction: The August 22 cover story, "Net Free," contained several errors. The Palmetto and Meske's skippers are rare in Florida. They were never thought to be extinct. Additionally, Butterfly World is located in Coconut Creek, and an incorrect name was given for the Miami Blue Butterfly Restoration Project.

KEEP NEW TIMES BROWARD-PALM BEACH FREE... Since we started New Times Broward-Palm Beach, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of South Florida, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.

Latest Stories