But her contrition, coming after years of steering county bond underwriting contracts to her husband's company and enjoying gifts of luxury hotel stays from a developer, was not enough to save her from a substantial stay in the slammer. U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks sentenced her to three-and-a-half years, plus three years supervised release and a $100,000 fine. This was more than the yearlong sentence she had requested and less than the five years prosecutors wanted.
Middlebrooks also remanded her immediately to jail, causing the reporters in the room to salivate over visions of the longtime politician cuffed and led off in disgrace. Instead, she was simply escorted out a back door of the courtroom, and the media were ordered out. "There she goes," one bystander observed.
In the subdued circus that followed, the entourage of McCarty supporters, opponents, and lawyers all stuffed into courtroom elevators with the reporters no one wanted to talk to. McCarty's lawyer, J. David Bogenschutz, told the TV cameras that he considered the sentence "a substantial break" from what she could have gotten, but she was obviously "not happy" with the immediate order to head to prison. She had been hoping to voluntarily surrender to a minimum-security prison such as the one where Martha Stewart served, putting her in a class with only the best celebrity crooks.
Watching the action outside the courthouse, Jupiter resident John Parsons was less-than-enthused. He had a yellow square with the number five pinned on his lapel, lobbying for McCarty to get the maximum punishment. "We were hoping to see justice done, but it was kinda half-justice," he said. "You get more than three-and-a-half years for stealing turtle eggs."
