On the face of it, British director Joe Wright, who brought us the ghosts of upper-crust England past with Pride & Prejudice and Atonement, seems an odd choice to direct a drama set in the Other Los Angeles. In fact, Wright, like Lopez, has a common touch, but the director is more a vulgarizer than a populist — a crucial difference when the subject is the wretched of the Earth. Using local non-pro actors, Wright pumps up Lopez's laconically described Skid Row into a Ken Russell hellhole of social outcasts and misfits. The Soloist begins with a flashy aerial shot of the downtown intersection between four freeways, followed by a meaningful cut to the dingy underpass below which Nathaniel Ayers (Jamie Foxx) lives with a shopping cart full of rubbish that he loves as much as the two-stringed old violin he plays to drown out the hostile voices in his head.
That's where Lopez (Robert Downey Jr.) stumbles across him playing Beethoven and where, being a few columns short, he proposes following Ayers around. For journalists like Lopez, it's a short hop from coverage to social work and, before long, under the eye-rolling gaze of wised-up community organizers, he's trying to press medication, music lessons, an apartment, and an appearance at Disney Hall on Nathaniel. Guess who's due for a steep learning curve?
Writing with matter-of-fact warmth and appealing self-deprecation of his efforts to fix an increasingly agitated Nathaniel, Lopez skillfully weaves in complex issues of patients' rights, the relationship between art and psychosis, and the thin line between journalism and advocacy. For his part, Wright, apparently seized with the fear that the material lacks inherent drama, lays on the hyperbole, peppering the action with in-your-face visuals and ill-lit flashbacks to Nathaniel's youth as a troubled Juilliard prodigy who freaked out his loving family. Instead of bumping into Ayers, as Lopez did while walking down a street, the writer meets him after being toppled from his bike and landing with a face full of blood in the county hospital's emergency room. To lighten things up, the writer has several labored run-ins with urine.
Worse yet, Lopez has been given a personality makeover. Whether in the interests of pathological symmetry or because this is how movies like their journalists, screenwriter Susannah Grant has turned the happily married Lopez into the ghost of Robert Downey Jr. past — a barely socialized basketcase, divorced from the sardonic but supportive wife and boss (Catherine Keener), who watches him succumb to his own delusions, then dusts him off and sets him straight. Stalwartly resisting the overkill, Downey delivers his lines and his unnecessary voice-over in a flat mumble that's astutely complemented by Foxx's low-key prattling. By turning down the volume, Foxx's beautifully modulated performance catches the way people with psychotic illnesses slip in and out of rationality and self-awareness. His Nathaniel is a sweet, self-effacing man, gifted but no genius, with a terrible illness he keeps at bay — up to a point — by replacing the menacing voices in his head with music. More clearly than his would-be savior does, Nathaniel understands that he lives on the streets because that's where he has nothing to lose and none of the pressures that drive him to violence when he's pushed too far.
Foxx and Downey's disciplined duet comes close to redeeming The Soloist from its visual excesses and the woolly romanticism about mental illness that Lopez so nimbly sidestepped. Never one to resist a cheesy finale, though, Wright leaves us with a parting shot of the dancing homeless that shamelessly exploits the very people his film is meant to champion.