Half Baked: Savory vs. Sweet | Clean Plate Charlie | South Florida | Broward Palm Beach New Times | The Leading Independent News Source in Broward-Palm Beach, Florida

Food News

Half Baked: Savory vs. Sweet

Patty Canedo is a chef in Palm Beach. She writes frequently about her kitchen exploits in this column, Half-Baked. Even in our post work getup a stranger still attempted to approach us,

"Hi, I'm Sarah. I'm a real chef," her majesty, the grill cook, took a victory sip of her cocktail after her jab at me.

"Hi, I'm Patty. I'm a skilled chef," the sip nearly came out her nose. She toasted my witty retort regarding my (then) pastry chef status-- a position that still remains the most challenging and intense that I've ever held in any kitchen

Ask either a pastry or savory chef if they could do the other's job and their ego will respond the same--a smirk and a quick "but it's been forever since I've done it". The reality is that neither one would work a shift in the other's clogs. Why?

Based on the most challenging and rewarding elements, here's my list of Savory Vs. Sweet from a woman with an affinity for both.

In the real world, you wouldn't pit a decadent, rich chocolate truffle against a tender filet mignon. In the kitchen there's a pretty definitive line between the sweet and the savory. Having added a taste of pastry to my repertoire gave me the opportunity to stand beside both chefs immersed in their element:

Look: Pastry

In all its glory, in any variety, using delicate hands, chocolate, cakes, sugar, etc. can be molded in any shape your imagination can take it.

Trim it, fabricate it, or hack it with a cleaver but that beautiful hunk of protein is still going to take a hauntingly falice shaped.

Temping: Savory

Equally challenging and sensitive to temperature but I've never had a dessert returned for being over or under cooked.

Timing: Savory & Pastry

In both cases, timing is everything but you can't pull a cake early to let it rest while you put the rest of the plate together. On the contrary, there are very few desserts made a la minute. The rich goodness of the dessert menu is ready for service just waiting to be plated. When you love the thrill of the rush where's the fun in that?

Creativity: Savory

Any chef will tell you that pastry is a science! Measurements, ingredients, everthing has to be precise and the margin of error is minimal. With savory there's room to play and add your own signature on a dish. I've stumbled onto some of my best recipes from an accident prepping the hotline. 

Patience: Pastry

We chefs are reknowned for our patience...wait for it......LOL! So having to take a steady hand to add delicate features to something that's already taken hours to create is not the pace most chefs like to work at. It's a real test of character as well as skill.

Tools: Savory and Pastry

Working the hotline all we really need to arm ourselves with is one sharp knife and a pair of tongs to get through the rush. Plus there's nothing like a new knife. Pastries need a little more finesse--tweezers, tips, off set and regular spatulas, the list is endless and the baggage gets to heavy quick. Course there's nothing like a new toy.


The most controversial argument amongst the toqued. Which takes more? While a baker may know what temp medium rare is and a cook may know how to make a souffle doesn't mean their positions on the line are interchangeable.

So which do you think that I prefer? I have an appreciation for both sides of the line but my heart belongs to...

Follow Clean Plate Charlie on Facebook and on Twitter: @CleanPlateBPB.

KEEP NEW TIMES BROWARD-PALM BEACH FREE... Since we started New Times Broward-Palm Beach, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of South Florida, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Patty Canedo

Latest Stories